# Merit aid follows your record, need-based aid follows your finances

Merit aid is money a college or group awards for grades, test scores, talent or achievement. Need-based aid is money awarded because the cost of attendance is higher than your Student Aid Index. A single college offer can hold both, and the rules for adding them together are written down by the federal government.

## Need-based aid is cost of attendance minus the Student Aid Index

The Federal Student Aid Handbook gives the test for financial need in one sentence: "Students are considered to have financial need if their COA exceeds their SAI." COA is the cost of attendance, the college's estimate of tuition, fees, housing, food, books and other costs for a year. SAI is the Student Aid Index, the number the FAFSA produces from your family's information.

So the math is simple. Take the college's cost of attendance. Subtract your SAI. What is left is your financial need at that college. Because every college has a different cost of attendance, the same family can have a large need at one college and a small need at another.

The Handbook calls the aid built on this number need-based: grants, loans and work-study that are based on demonstrated financial need. Your FAFSA is the starting point for all of it.

## Merit aid is set by the college's own rules, not by your SAI

The same Handbook chapter contrasts need-based aid with "scholarship programs that may award funds based on academic merit or the student's field of study." Merit aid is that second kind. A college, a state or an outside group decides what record earns the award.

Look at a real grid. Mississippi State University publishes tiers for in-state freshmen that pair an ACT or SAT range with a GPA band, and each box has a yearly dollar amount. The tiers on that page are built from test score, GPA and residency.

That is why a student with a high GPA can see a merit award at a college where the family's SAI is high. It is also why two students with the same GPA can see different offers: the college may count residency, test scores or a major.

The [Automatic Merit Table](https://whatisameritscholarship.com/colleges-with-merit-scholarships/) lists the colleges that post their cutoffs in this way. Read the [method page](https://whatisameritscholarship.com/colleges-with-merit-scholarships/method/) to see how each cutoff was recorded.

## One offer can hold both kinds, and the packaging rule limits the total

A college puts your aid together in a step called packaging. The Handbook states the general rule this way: "the student's need-based aid must not exceed the student's financial need." It adds that your total aid plus other financial assistance must not exceed your cost of attendance.

Two limits follow. First, need-based aid cannot go past your financial need. Second, nothing in the package can push the total past the cost of attendance.

Here is what that looks like in plain words. Say a college's cost of attendance is higher than your SAI, so you have need. The college can offer need-based grants, loans and work-study up to that need. It can also add a merit scholarship. Whether the merit award counts against the need-based pieces depends on the college's own packaging policy, and the pages used for this guide do not state one policy for all colleges.

So read each offer letter line by line. Mark which lines are grants or scholarships, which are loans and which are work-study. Then ask the aid office how the merit line was treated.

## Outside scholarships count as aid under 34 CFR 673.5

A scholarship from an outside group is also part of your aid picture. Under 34 CFR 673.5(c), the federal rule counts "Scholarships, including athletic scholarships" as part of a student's estimated financial assistance.

The same section sets a limit that is easy to read past. An institution may award an FSEOG or a Perkins loan only if that loan or the FSEOG, "combined with the other estimated financial assistance the student receives, does not exceed the student's financial need." That is the overaward rule in federal wording. If an outside award pushes the total past need, the college may have to adjust campus-based aid.

The Handbook shows the order with an example. The aid administrator "begins by awarding a Pell Grant and applying an outside scholarship before awarding Campus-Based aid." In its example, a $400 outside scholarship and a Pell Grant are subtracted from cost of attendance minus SAI to reach the need that is left.

What a given college reduces first is its own policy. The guide on [outside scholarships and merit offers](https://whatisameritscholarship.com/guides/outside-scholarships-and-merit-offers/) lists four colleges' written policies.

## A new Pell Grant limit starts with the 2026-27 award year

The Handbook notes one change for 2026-27. Students cannot receive Pell Grant funds for any period in which non-federal grant or scholarship aid equals or exceeds their cost of attendance. The Handbook describes this aid as funds from non-federal sources that a student need not earn or pay back.

This matters only when merit and outside awards are very large compared with the cost of attendance. If your scholarships come close to the full cost, ask the aid office in writing whether the Pell rule applies to you for that period.

Notice what this rule does not say. It does not say merit aid is bad for you or that you should turn an award down. It sets a ceiling on stacking federal Pell money on top of non-federal aid that already covers the whole cost.

## If merit aid covers more than your need, read the situation page

Some families get a merit award that is larger than their financial need. The packaging rule above then decides what a college may do with the rest of the package. Colleges differ, and the federal text sets limits rather than a single outcome.

The page on [when merit aid is more than your need](https://whatisameritscholarship.com/situations/too-much-for-need/) walks through the questions to ask. The short version is to request a revised offer in writing and ask which lines changed, loans or grants, and why.

Two habits help. Keep the original offer letter and every revised copy. And compare offers by the total you pay after grants and scholarships, not by the size of the headline scholarship. A large merit number at a high-cost college can leave a larger bill than a smaller number at a low-cost college.

## Questions this guide answers

**Does merit aid depend on my family's income?**

The merit grids on college pages, such as Mississippi State University's, are built from GPA, test score and residency. Need-based aid is the part tied to cost of attendance minus your SAI.

**What is the Student Aid Index?**

It is the number the FAFSA produces from your family's information. The FSA Handbook says you have financial need if the cost of attendance exceeds your SAI.

**Can I get merit aid and need-based aid in the same offer?**

Yes, an offer can list both. The Handbook rule is that need-based aid must not exceed financial need and total aid must not exceed cost of attendance.

**Does an outside scholarship count as aid?**

Yes. 34 CFR 673.5(c) counts scholarships as part of a student's estimated financial assistance, so the aid office may adjust other aid.

## Sources

- FSA Handbook 2026-27, Vol 3 Ch 3: Packaging aid: https://fsapartners.ed.gov/knowledge-center/fsa-handbook/2026-2027/vol3/ch3-packaging-aid (read November 18, 2026)
- FSA Handbook 2026-27, Vol 3 Ch 2: Cost of attendance: https://fsapartners.ed.gov/knowledge-center/fsa-handbook/2026-2027/vol3/ch2-cost-attendance-budget (read November 18, 2026)
- 34 CFR 673.5, eCFR: https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-34/subtitle-B/chapter-VI/part-673/subpart-A/section-673.5 (read November 18, 2026)
- Mississippi State University freshman scholarships: https://sfa.msstate.edu/scholarships/state-freshman-scholarships (read November 18, 2026)

Last reviewed November 18, 2026

Canonical: https://whatisameritscholarship.com/guides/merit-vs-need-based-aid/
