Need-based aid depends on your family's finances, not your grades
Need-based aid is financial aid, such as grants, loans and work-study, awarded because a student's cost of attendance is higher than what the family is expected to pay. The Federal Student Aid Handbook says a student has need if cost of attendance exceeds the Student Aid Index. Merit aid looks at grades, scores or talent instead.
In more detail
Federal need-based aid starts with the FAFSA. The result is your Student Aid Index. A college subtracts that number from its cost of attendance, and the gap is your financial need. Grants, work-study and loans can fill part or all of that gap, up to the limits the college and the federal rules set.
Merit aid does not use that gap. A student with no need can still receive a merit award, and a student with high need can receive both. The overlap matters later: when total aid passes a limit, a college may reduce need-based pieces first. Read merit vs need-based aid for how packages are put together.
A real example
The Federal Student Aid Handbook for 2026-2027 states the test plainly: "Students are considered to have financial need if their COA exceeds their SAI." COA is cost of attendance and SAI is the Student Aid Index. Source: FSA Handbook, Volume 3, Chapter 3.
Sources
- FSA Handbook 2026-2027, Vol. 3, Ch. 3: Packaging Aid, read November 18, 2026
- FSA Handbook 2026-2027, Vol. 3, Ch. 2: Cost of Attendance, read November 18, 2026
Last reviewed November 18, 2026
Spotted an error? Write to editor@whatisameritscholarship.com. Corrections are logged on the corrections page.