Compare two merit offers on the same five lines
A bigger award is not always the better offer: a $16,000-a-year award that needs a 3.5 to renew can be worth less than a $10,000 one you keep with a 2.5. Put each yearly amount next to the college's cost of attendance, then check renewal GPA, years and residency.
Start with the yearly amount, then the cost
Write each offer as a yearly dollar figure. If the award letter gives a four-year total, divide it by the number of years the letter says it lasts.
Then find the cost of attendance for the same year at each college. It is on the college's financial aid or tuition page, and the college's net price calculator estimates what a family pays after aid. Use those pages, not a ranking site, and note the year printed on them.
The Federal Student Aid Handbook says students have financial need if their cost of attendance exceeds their Student Aid Index. For a merit award, the useful comparison is simpler: cost of attendance minus every award on the letter.
Per year or a total
Read the amount wording carefully.
The University of Kansas prints both: for its KU Excellence tier, $64,000 over four years, which is $16,000 per year. Mississippi State University does the same: $76,000 over four years, $19,000 per year.
Georgia Southern University's first-year merit award is a one-time amount for the first academic year, and it is non-renewable. See Georgia Southern University.
The University of Montana lists $12,500 to $18,000 on its Academic Achievement page and does not say whether the figure is per year or a total. When a page does not say, ask the admissions or scholarship office to state it in writing before you compare. See University of Montana.
Renewal: GPA, credits and years
Most awards last up to four years if you meet a renewal rule. The rule is part of the offer.
At the University of Kansas, you keep the award with a 3.0 KU GPA and full-time enrollment, for a first bachelor's degree or eight continuous semesters. At Michigan Technological University, the renewal GPA is 2.50 at the end of each spring semester, and the page says students live in the university's residence halls for their first and second years.
Some pages leave a piece out. The University of Louisville states that its awards are renewable but does not state the renewal GPA or number of years on the page read. Ohio University's Admission Promise Award requires the FAFSA each year by the priority date.
If a page is silent, ask. The keeping a merit scholarship guide covers what to do if your GPA drops.
Residency and conditions
Check whether the award depends on your state of residence. A resident tier and a nonresident tier can pay very different amounts at the same college, as at Kansas, where the 3.25 GPA tiers are $1,000 in-state and $8,000 out-of-state. See out-of-state merit aid.
Look for conditions that cost money or limit choices: a required major (Boise State notes eligible-major requirements for its nonresident Ridgeline and Summit awards), housing, full-time enrollment, or a deadline.
Also look at the deadline. Kansas lists December 1 for a complete application, and Boise State lists December 15 for nonresidents.
Stacking with outside awards and other aid
Colleges differ in what they reduce when an outside scholarship arrives. Virginia Tech says it reduces loans and work-study before other scholarships and grants. The University of Kansas says it often starts by reducing or canceling loans, but sometimes reduces grants or other need-based aid.
Federal rules matter too. The Handbook says need-based aid must not exceed financial need and that total aid must not exceed the cost of attendance. For 2026-27, students cannot receive Pell Grant funds for any period in which non-federal grant or scholarship aid equals or exceeds their cost of attendance.
Ask each aid office in writing how it treats outside awards. The outside scholarships guide goes further.
A worked example: Kansas and Michigan Tech
For example, take an out-of-state applicant with a 3.75 GPA and no test score, comparing two colleges with GPA-only nonresident tiers.
The University of Kansas places a 3.75 GPA in KU Achievement, which is $12,000 per year ($48,000 over four years). Renewal needs a 3.0 KU GPA and full-time enrollment.
Michigan Technological University places a 3.75 GPA in its nonresident tier for 3.75 to 3.899 at $15,000 per year. Renewal needs a 2.50 GPA each spring, and first- and second-year housing in the residence halls is required.
The gap is $3,000 per year, or $12,000 over four years if both awards renew. That tells you nothing about your bill yet. Open each college's cost of attendance page or net price calculator, subtract the award, and add any housing or other conditions.
Questions this guide answers
Which matters more, the award size or the renewal GPA?
Both. A large award you lose after one year can cost more than a smaller one you keep. Compare the yearly amount and the renewal rule together.
Where do I find the cost of attendance?
On each college's financial aid or tuition page, and in its net price calculator. Use the figure for the same year as the award.
What if an offer does not say per year or total?
Ask the admissions or scholarship office to confirm in writing before you compare.
Can an outside scholarship shrink my college award?
It can. Policies differ. Virginia Tech and the University of Kansas both say they often reduce loans first. Ask each college.
Sources
- University of Kansas freshman scholarships, read November 18, 2026
- Mississippi State University freshman scholarships, read November 18, 2026
- Georgia Southern University scholarships, read November 18, 2026
- University of Montana Academic Achievement Scholarship, read November 18, 2026
- Michigan Technological University scholarships, read November 18, 2026
- Boise State University New to College scholarships, read November 18, 2026
- Ohio University Excellence Awards, read November 18, 2026
- Virginia Tech outside scholarship policy, read November 18, 2026
- University of Kansas outside scholarship policy, read November 18, 2026
- Federal Student Aid Handbook 2026-27, packaging aid, read November 18, 2026
- Federal Student Aid Handbook 2026-27, cost of attendance, read November 18, 2026
Last reviewed November 18, 2026
Spotted an error? Write to editor@whatisameritscholarship.com. Corrections are logged on the corrections page.